Palestine Cry

The Truth of God and Our Lord Jesus Christ

Special Palestine Cry Blog articles: The Catholic Creed: The meaning of the Pasch of Christians.

JESUS CHRIST IS THE ONLY WAY AND TRUTH AND LIFE - NO ONE COMES TO THE FATHER EXCEPT BY HIM.

For as it was not possible that the man who had once for all been conquered, and who had been destroyed through disobedience, could reform himself, and obtain the prize of victory; and as it was also impossible that he could attain to salvation who had fallen under the power of sin,-the Son effected both these things, being the Word of God, descending from the Father, becoming incarnate, stooping low, even to death, and consummating the arranged plan of our salvation, upon whom [Paul], exhorting us unhesitatingly to believe, again says, "Who shall ascend into heaven? that is, to bring down Christ; or who shall descend into the deep? that is, to liberate Christ again from the dead." Then he continues, "If thou shall confess with thy mouth the Lord Jesus, and shalt believe in thine heart that God hath raised Him from the dead, thou shall be saved." And he renders the reason why the Son of God did these things, saying, "For to this end Christ both lived, and died, and revived, that He might rule over the living and the dead." And again, writing to the Corinthians, he declares, "But we preach Christ Jesus crucified; "and adds, "The cup of blessing which we bless, is it not the communion of the blood of Christ? " - St. Irenaeus, Against Heresies, Book III, Chapter XVIII, Section 2.

The Crucifixion of the Lord Jesus Christ, Mary and John and the women at the foot of the Cross

Matthew 27:45 Now from the sixth hour, there was darkness over all the earth, until the ninth hour.

Origen tell us this darkness was only in Palestine, and the neighbouring countries: for as to the words, over the whole earth, or over the whole land, we find one kingdom or empire, by a common way of speaking, called the whole earth, or the whole world. As to the cause of the obscuration of the sun; and secondly, as to the extent of its darkness. Origen tells us that the darkness was partial, and confined to Judea and the neighbouring countries, as the darkness of Egypt was only perceived in that country, and not in Gessen, where the children of Israel were. Saint Jerome tells us that the obscurity was caused by the rays of the sun being suddenly withdrawn by divine power, as was the case in Egypt. The darkness in Egypt during the Passover of Moses was due to God's protection withdrawn from that land at that time. The darkness when Christ was Crucified for us is the judgement of God upon His Son Jesus Christ, in our place. For Jesus Christ knew NO sin. He never sinned, nor could He ever.

The meaning of the Pasch of Christians.

The Book of Wisdom, Chapter 17, describes the devils and demons thrown back upon the Egyptians when the Israelites under Moses were brought out of Egypt by God for God’s purposes (to prepare a place for the Crucifixion of Our Lord for the Redemption of the whole world of those who are saved). In the same way the same false gods and goddesses that the Egyptians served and which in so doing were the reason the Egyptians sacrificed their sons and daughters to the devils and demons behind the false gods/goddesses were the spirits that killed the Egyptian children that perished when the Israelites were brought out of Egypt. God does not murder children, period. The angel of death which destroyed in Egypt was one of the fallen spirits. God did not cause any of the fallen spirits to hurt anyone. God allowed the fallen spirits to do what it is their nature do to when He brought the Israelites out of the gates of hell which was Egypt. The children below the age of reason that died went to be with God for eternity, they will be resurrected with the just at the Second Coming of Christ. This principle of God allowing the innocent to be afflicted along with guilty finds its ultimate fulfillment in Christ’s singular and only salvific Kenosis. Jesus Christ committed no sin, not ever nor could He, and was and is and only could be utterly and absolutely and completely innocent of any and all wrongdoing and sin by His very nature as the Holy and True God. The guiltless sacrificed by His own will for the guilty. Even when the innocent are afflicted by the actions and evils instigated by the fallen spirits in the world, the innocent are not possessed by those fallen spirits. The principle of all being afflicted by the evil set loose upon the world for its unrepentant sin will occur when the universal plagues are let loose upon the world. See Apocalypse 16 –

The principle of our always, for our part, protecting children is given us by Our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ in the Gospel of Matthew, Chapter 18

1 At *that hour the disciples came to Jesus, saying: Who, thinkest thou, is the greater in the kingdom of heaven?

2 *And Jesus calling unto him a little child, set him in the midst of them,

3 And said: Amen I say unto you, *unless you be converted, and become as little children, you shall not enter into the kingdom of heaven.

4 Whosoever therefore shall humble himself as this little child, he is the greater in the kingdom of heaven.

5 And he that shall receive one such little child in my name, receiveth me.

10 Take heed that you despise not one of these little ones: for I say to you, *that their angels in heaven always see the face of my Father who is in heaven.

The principle of our ONLY worshipping the True God, the Father and the Son Jesus Christ and the Holy Spirit is given first in the historical truth of the Garden of Eden when Christ, who is the Tree of Life commands the first man and his wife, Adam and Eve to not have anything to do with the tree of the knowledge of good and evil which is Satan, the first fallen angel, nor with any of the fallen angels with Satan. Assisi of Babylon/Vatican/Rome is absolute and complete violation of that principle and is the Great Apostasy in full blown Satanic evil. Have nothing to do with the Vatican or suffer its eternal damnation in hell with it. The devil and demon worshipping pagans and the perfidious deicidal Jews are not ever any part of the Salvific action of Christ upon Golgotha/Calvary. Individual pagans and Jews if they repent of their not confessing Jesus Christ as the Immortal Son of God become flesh for our sake and sacrificed for our salvation and who confess publicly their sin of devil and demon worshipping and perfidy and deicide and who beg the Lord of all, the Lord God, the Father and the Son Jesus Christ and the Holy Spirit for forgiveness of their horrid and abominable sins, can and will be forgiven if they do so now in this life and will enter into the only path of salvation there is as dictated by God Himself. The Church, all the faithful – there is no other meaning acceptable to God for the word Church, is commanded by God to not have anything to do with the Apostasy.

Book of Wisdom, Chapter 17

1 For thy judgments, O Lord, are great, and thy words cannot be expressed: therefore undisciplined souls have erred.

2 For while the wicked thought to be able to have dominion over the holy nation, they themselves being fettered with the bonds of darkness, and a long night, shut up in their houses, lay there exiled from the eternal providence.

3 And while they thought to lie hid in their obscure sins, they were scattered under a dark veil of forgetfulness, being horribly afraid and troubled with exceeding great astonishment.

4 For neither did the den that held them, keep them from fear: for noises coming down troubled them, and sad visions appearing to them, affrighted them.

5 And no power of fire could give them light, neither could the bright flames of the stars enlighten that horrible night.

6 But there appeared to them a sudden fire, very dreadful: and being struck with the fear of that face, which was not seen, they thought the things which they saw to be worse:

7 And the delusions of their magic art were put down, and their boasting of wisdom was reproachfully rebuked.

8 For they who promised to drive away fears and troubles from a sick soul, were sick themselves of a fear worthy to be laughed at.

9 For though no terrible thing disturbed them: yet being scared with the passing by of beasts, and hissing of serpents, they died for fear: and denying that they saw the air, which could by no means be avoided.

10 For whereas wickedness is fearful, it beareth witness of its condemnation: for a troubled conscience always forecasteth grievous things.

11 For fear is nothing else but a yielding up of the succours from thought.

12 And while there is less expectation from within, the greater doth it count the ignorance of that cause which bringeth the torment.

13 But they that during that night, in which nothing could be done, and which came upon them from the lowest and deepest hell, slept the same sleep.

14 Were sometimes molested with the fear of monsters, sometimes fainted away, their soul failing them: for a sudden and unlooked for fear was come upon them.

15 Moreover if any of them had fallen down, he was kept shut up in prison without irons.

16 For if any one were a husbandman, or a shepherd, or a labourer in the field, and was suddenly overtaken, he endured a necessity from which he could not fly.

17 For they were all bound together with one chain of darkness. Whether it were a whistling wind, or the melodious voice of birds, among the spreading branches of trees, or a fall of water running down with violence,

18 Or the mighty noise of stones tumbling down, or the running that could not be seen of beasts playing together, or the roaring voice of wild beasts, or a rebounding echo from the highest mountains: these things made them to swoon for fear.

19 For the whole world was enlightened with a clear light, and none were hindered in their labours.

20 But over them only was spread a heavy night, an image of that darkness which was to come upon them. But they were to themselves more grievous than the darkness.

The Catholic Creed: The Final Trial: Traditional Catholic Prayers: Baptism

Showing posts with label Fritz Edlinger. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fritz Edlinger. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 12, 2011

European Diplomats Draft Demands Jerusalem Protection

European Diplomats Draft Demands Jerusalem Protection

[use Open Image in New Window to see pictures in full enlarged]

The European draft report quoted below recommends the imposition of punitive measures against Israel as a protest of its regime of continuous building of colonies (settlements) in the occupied territories and Jerusalem and the continued demolition of Palestinian houses. Among the EU recommendations: “Deployment of EU observers in the places of settlement construction and demolitions, dealing with East Jerusalem as capital of a future State of Palestine, and re-open PLO offices in Jerusalem”. The report – drafted by representatives of European missions in Jerusalem and Ramallah, most of them in the rank of consul, was recently submitted to the European Union – demands from the EU to tighten the steps to protest against Israel and is the continuation of a document by European consuls submitted about a year ago.

The full text of the European report was sent to me by Mr. Fritz Eidlnger, General Secretary of Society of Austro-Arab Relations and is re-published below. See report as (PDF EU report on Jerusalem Dec 2011).

EU HEADS OF MISSION
Cover Note

Considering the EU’s commitment to the two-state solution with an independent, democratic, contiguous and viable Palestinian state, comprising the West Bank, including East Jerusalem, and Gaza, living side by side in peace and security with the State of Israel;

Considering the developments in East Jerusalem and in particular the progressive separation of East Jerusalem from the rest of the West Bank, as demonstrated by the Jerusalem Report;

Considering the urgent need to address the situation in conformity with the EU position, in accordance with international law, that the acquisition of territory by force or the threat of the use of force is inadmissible;

Considering the EU Council Conclusions of 8 December 2009;

The Heads of Mission in Jerusalem and Ramallah herewith submit to the PSC the Jerusalem Report 2010 (Annex 1) and for discussion a series of recommendations to reinforce EU policy on East Jerusalem (Annex 2):

The Heads of Mission in Jerusalem and Ramallah recommend:

  • - A more active and visible implementation of EU policy on East Jerusalem.
  • - Using meetings with Israeli authorities to give a clear and consistent message on East
    Jerusalem.
  • - Appropriate follow-up to the submissions.
  • - Mandating HoMs in Jerusalem and Ramallah to continue the work to reinforce the
    EU policy on East Jerusalem.

[Annex 1]

EU HEADS OF MISSION REPORT ON EAST JERUSALEM

JERUSALEM AND THE PEACE PROCESS

1. Jerusalem is one of the most complex issues to be addressed in any peace process. The city embodies the essence of the conflict: territory, nationhood and religion. Since its occupation and annexation by Israel (illegal under international law and not accepted by the international community), the increasing integration of East Jerusalem into Israel has left Palestinian neighborhoods ever more isolated. Israel is, by legal and practical means, actively pursuing its annexation by systematically undermining the Palestinian presence in the city. A recent Israeli law requires a two-thirds majority in the Knesset or approval in a referendum for withdrawal from occupied East Jerusalem. Moreover, the past year has again seen a further deterioration of the overall situation in East Jerusalem. If current trends are not stopped as a matter of urgency, the prospect of East Jerusalem as the future capital of a Palestinian state becomes increasingly unlikely and unworkable. This, in turn, seriously endangers the chances of a sustainable peace on the basis of two states, with Jerusalem as their future capital.

Palestinian boy urinates of fear being grabbed by israeli special forces in Jerusalem.

2. The continued expansion of settlements, restrictive zoning and planning, ongoing demolitions and evictions, an inequitable education policy, difficult access to health care, the inadequate provision of resources and investment and the precarious residency issue have not only serious humanitarian consequences, they undermine the Palestinian presence in East Jerusalem. The interlinked Israeli policies and measures continue to negatively affect East Jerusalem’s crucial role in Palestinian political, economic, social and cultural life. This has contributed to the increasing separation between East Jerusalem and the rest of the West Bank and Gaza. The wider political consequences of the above measures are of great concern. Over the past few years the changes to the city have run counter to the peace process. Attempts to exclusively emphasize the Jewish identity of the city threaten its religious diversity and radicalise the conflict, with potential regional and global repercussions. The interest of safeguarding the religious, historical and symbolic values of Jerusalem goes beyond the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. This EU HOMs Report on East Jerusalem aims to provide an update on the situation in the city and policy recommendations.

IDF chasing women at a checkpoint at the entrance of Jerusalem.

EU POLICY

3. EU policy regarding East Jerusalem is based on the principles set out in UN Security Council Resolution 242, notably the inadmissibility of acquisition of territory by force. In accordance with international law, the EU regards East Jerusalem as occupied territory and has never recognised the Israeli 1980 Basic Law (Jerusalem, Capital of Israel) which annexed Jerusalem as Israel’s “complete and united” capital and modified the city’s municipal borders. This is in line with UNSC Resolution 478 in which the Security Council decided not to recognise this Basic Law and other actions that “seek
to alter the character and status of Jerusalem”. The resolution also calls upon all UN Members that had established diplomatic missions in Jerusalem “to withdraw such missions from the Holy city”. The EU considers Jerusalem as a final status issue in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and opposes any measures that would prejudge the outcome of peace negotiations, such as actions aimed at changing the status of East Jerusalem.

4. In conferences held in 1999 and 2001, the High Contracting Parties to the Fourth Geneva Convention reaffirmed the applicability of the Convention to the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, and reiterated the need for full respect for the provisions of the said Convention in that territory.

5. In 2004, the EU acknowledged the Advisory Opinion of the International Court of Justice (ICJ) on the “Legal Consequences of the Construction of a Wall in the Occupied Palestinian Territory”. While the EU recognises Israel’s security concerns and its right to act in self-defence, its position coincides with the ICJ Advisory Opinion according to which the sections of the barrier route which run inside the West Bank, including East Jerusalem, together with the associated gate and permit regime, violate Israel’s obligations under international law.

6. The Council conclusions of 8 December 2009 reaffirm the longstanding EU policy. According to the Conclusions, the EU will not recognise any changes to the pre-1967 borders including with regard to Jerusalem, other than those agreed by the parties. The EU has never recognised the annexation of East Jerusalem and states that “if there is to be a genuine peace, a way must be found through negotiations to resolve the status of Jerusalem as the future capital of two states”. The EU has repeatedly urged the Government of Israel to immediately end all settlement activities in East Jerusalem which the EU considers illegal under international law and calls on the Israeli government to cease all discriminatory treatment of Palestinians in East Jerusalem

SETTLEMENTS
7. The demographic factor is a central element in Israeli policy. In 1967, Israel extended its jurisdiction over East Jerusalem. At the same time, by adding some 70 km² it redefined the municipal boundaries of Jerusalem. Today, some 924 000 people live within these municipal boundaries, of which around 30 percent are Palestinian. It has been a stated aim in official planning documents to prevent the Palestinian population from becoming more than 30 percent of the municipality’s total population.

Successive Israeli governments have pursued a policy of transferring Jewish population into the occupied Palestinian territory (oPt) in violation of the Fourth Geneva Convention and international humanitarian law. In East Jerusalem 35 percent of the land has been expropriated for “state land”. Only citizens of Israel or those legally entitled to claim Israeli citizenship (i.e. Jewish) can buy property built on state land. As a consequence, out of a total of more than 500 000 settlers in occupied Palestinian land some 190 000 Israeli settlers today live in settlements inside East Jerusalem. Between 2001 and 2009, 37 percent of all settlement housing units in the occupied Palestinian territory were located in East Jerusalem.

8. In 2003, Israel committed under the Roadmap to reach a permanent agreement that would include a negotiated solution on the status of Jerusalem and to freeze all settlement activity, including “natural growth”. The Israeli government reaffirmed its Roadmap commitment to a settlement freeze at the Annapolis conference in 2007. In November 2009, the Israeli government announced a 10-month settlement moratorium (expiring at the end of September 2010) which resulted in a partial freeze of construction of new settlement housing units in occupied Palestinian territory. However, based on Israeli claims that the Jerusalem municipality constitutes Israeli territory, the commitment to stop settlement activity has never been interpreted by the Israeli government as applying to East Jerusalem. For several months during the first half of 2010, a decrease of settlement activity in East Jerusalem has been noted. Since the end of the moratorium, however, renewed settlement activity has taken place.

9. There are two kinds of settlements in Jerusalem:

  • a) Small settlement buildings or compounds established by ideologically motivated settlers predominantly in the Old City and the Historic Basin. By establishing these settlements in the midst of Palestinian neighbourhoods the settlers are creating new facts on the ground by attempting to prevent a division of the city, taking advantage of the so called Clinton parameters (i.e. an understanding that neighbourhoods that are Jewish will become Israel and those that are inhabited by Palestinians will become part of a Palestinian state).
  • b) Israeli Government initiated Jewish “neighbourhoods” built on land occupied by Israel in 1967. These settlements can be divided into two rings – outer and inner – which squeeze East Jerusalem and separate Palestinians from the city.

Settlements in the Old City – Historic Basin

10. The Old City and its immediate environs to the south and east are commonly referred to collectively as the Historic Basin. This area includes the Palestinian neighbourhoods of Silwan, Ras al- Amud, At-Tur, Wadi al-Joz and Sheikh Jarrah and contains the majority of the historical and holy sites of Jerusalem. These are Palestinian residential areas, but since the occupation of East Jerusalem in 1967, the land has progressively fallen under the control of various pro-settlement Jewish organisations. Today, it is estimated that around 5000 settlers live in the area. The focus of the settler organisations has included settlement activity related to excavation of archaeological sites, services for tourists and recreational facilities. In spite of the fact that these activities are often being implemented
by private organisations, such as Ataret Cohanim and El’ad (see archaeology section), they still form part of an overall pro-settlement strategy, the realisation of which is facilitated by the Government of Israel as well as the Jerusalem municipality.

11. The strategic settlement push is made evident through the continued expansion of settlement activities around and within the Historic Basin. This creates a settlement continuum, comprised by a swath of smaller settlements, public parks, archaeological sites and tourist complexes along the eastern and southern wall of the Old City. These activities effectively encircle and contain the Historic Basin, cut off the territorial contiguity between the Palestinian neighbourhoods of East Jerusalem and the Old
City and separate the Muslim and Christian holy places from the rest of East Jerusalem.

12. Various methods are used to strategically gain control of Palestinian properties: through the Absentee Property Law, on the basis of claimed Jewish ownership (pre-1948), or through the purchase from the owners. As a consequence, land and property have gradually fallen under the control of various private settler organizations, often with state support. Documents released in early November 2010 point to irregularities in the way that Israeli state-seized land was passed to settlement organisations without the proper tender processes and due diligence. This raises questions over the extent of influence settlement organisations enjoy inside the relevant authorities. At the same time, under Israeli law Palestinians are precluded from reclaiming pre-1948 property in Israel or in West Jerusalem.

13. Moreover, private Israeli settler organisations have continued to take over property within the Old City where today the number of Jewish settlers is estimated at around 4000. These settlers presently occupy property in all quarters of the Old City. Often these properties are wedged tightly in between existing Palestinian dwellings (sometimes settlers will occupy individual apartments in buildings also inhabited by Palestinian families). The close proximity between settlers and Palestinians in the Old City only adds to the considerable tension that already exists in the area. In July 2010, settlers seized a two-storey house in the Muslim quarter, thereby displacing several Palestinian families. In Sheikh Jarrah, preparations for building activity are in place on the Shepherd’s Hotel site. In March 2010, building permits were issued for 20 new housing units on the site.

14. In January 2010, the Municipality approved construction permits for 24 new apartments in four buildings in the private settlement of Beit Orot on the Mount of Olives. There are currently 14 families and 80 yeshiva students living in the settlement which is in the middle of a Palestinian neighbourhood. In the neighbourhood of Ras al-Amud, renovation and construction work started for 14 new apartments in the old Police Station, although the permits have not yet been issued. The plan is to expand the nearby settlement of Ma’ale Zeitim from 60 housing units to more than 200 by incorporating this new site.

15. Concerns remain about the Open Spaces project, which foresees, inter alia, in the establishment of a sequence of gardens and parks around the Old City, running through Palestinian neighbourhoods. The plan risks furthering limit Palestinian construction and living space in East Jerusalem.

The Inner Settlement Ring
16. The inner ring comprises large government-initiated settlements within the Israeli-defined municipal boundary of Jerusalem. They are home to approximately 190 000 Israeli settlers. Wedged in between East Jerusalem and the rest of the West Bank, these settlements in combination with the barrier effectively cut Jerusalem off from the rest of the West Bank.

Israeli border police officers wearing gasmasks at the Kalandia checkpoint between the West Bank city of Ramallah and Jerusalem.Pic. Creidt: AP Muhammed Muheisen

17. As from November 2010, administrative planning procedures for settlement activity in East Jerusalem have resumed very intensively. Four new town plan schemes (the first since March) have been approved for public review, altogether for 1 275 new housing units in the settlements Ramot and Har Homa and 625 in Pisgat Ze’ev. The expansion of Har Homa, in particular, implies the further completion of the inner ring as it foresees housing units outside the already built-up area. Also in November 2010, the Israeli authorities advanced East Jerusalem settlement construction by issuing tenders for the construction of 238 housing units in the settlements of Ramot and Pisgat Zeev. An additional 479 tenders were issued for construction in Har Homa, Gilo, Pisgat Ze’ev and East Talpiot (on the basis of plans approved prior to 2010). Finally, the implementation of a controversial construction project to build four new hotels, with 1 400 rooms in No-Man’s Land near Talpiot was revived in early July (but has been temporarily shelved following international protest).

The Outer Settlement Ring
18. The outer ring consists of settlements outside Jerusalem’s municipal boundary but largely on the west side of the barrier. These settlements further isolate Jerusalem from the rest of the West Bank. They include the three main “settlement blocks”: Giv’at Ze’ev, Ma’ale Adumim and the Gush Etzion bloc, home to approximately 100 000 settlers.
19. Concerns remain about areas that have been designed for further settlement expansion, such as the E1 area (situated between Jerusalem and the Ma’ale Adumim settlement). In this area, there is a longstanding plan to build a new settlement with 3 500 units for around 14 500 settlers. The plan includes an industrial park, a police station, large-scale infrastructure, commercial development and recreational facilities. In 2008, the police headquarters of “Judea and Samaria” moved to E1. The implementation of the E1 project would not only divide the West Bank into a northern and a southern part but also, by establishing contiguity between the settlements and Jerusalem, be the final step to geographically cutting off East Jerusalem from the rest of the West Bank.

ARCHAEOLOGY
20. A clear example of government involvement in settlement activities in the Historic Basin is the outsourcing of archaeological undertakings to private Israeli pro-settlement organisations. The use of archaeology as a politico-ideological tool in the Wadi Hilweh area just south of the Temple Mount/Haram Al-Sharif (often referred to as the “City of David” area) is a source of increasing concern. According to historic accounts, biblical Jerusalem originated in this area some 3 000 years ago and the place has been the subject of numerous archaeological excavations throughout the last century.

21. The management of the various archaeological sites in Wadi Hilweh/City of David has now been largely placed in the hands of a pro-settlement Jewish NGO by the name of El’ad. Over the years this organisation has successfully obtained an increasing amount of government funding for its archaeological undertakings. The organisation has entered into a partnership with the Israel Antiquities Authority which is paid directly by El’ad to physically carry out the excavations without Palestinian involvement or international oversight. Furthermore, with the support of the Jerusalem municipality, El’ad has been successful in securing a contract from the Israel Nature and Parks authority to manage
an archaeological visitors’ park in Wadi Hilweh/City of David. Consequently, not only the excavation, but also the presentation of the archaeology of ancient Jerusalem has been outsourced to El’ad.

22. This has resulted in a strong monopolisation of the historical narrative, exploiting the biblical and Jewish-Israeli connotations of the area while effectively disenfranchising Arab/Muslim claims of historic-archaeological ties to the very same place. The overarching purpose of such a pre-programmed approach to the presentation of archaeological evidence in the area seems to be a concerted effort to utilize archaeology to enhance a claimed historic Jewish continuity in Jerusalem, thereby creating a historic justification for the establishment of Jerusalem as the eternal and undivided capital of Israel.

PLANNING, DEMOLITIONS AND EVICTIONS
23. The planning regime of the Jerusalem municipality remains a source of concern as it places severe restrictions on the building of Palestinian housing in East Jerusalem. Many Palestinians live under the threat of having their house demolished and being evicted, adding to the existing tensions. These restrictions result in a housing shortage in East Jerusalem and regular demolitions of Palestinian-owned structures.

24. According to the planning regime, 13 percent of the land in East Jerusalem is currently zoned for Palestinian construction (compared to 35 percent which is allocated for Israeli settlements). Only within this 13 percent, which is already densely built upon, Palestinians have the possibility of obtaining an Israeli-issued permit to build, repair or maintain their homes and livelihood-related structures. Administrative requirements, however, make it extremely difficult for Palestinian residents in East Jerusalem to obtain such permits. In addition, the procedures take several years and usually entail a prohibitive cost.

25. Over the past years Palestinians have received fewer than 200 building permits per year. Based on the population growth, permits for 1 500 housing units annually would be necessary to cover the housing needs.

26. As a consequence of the restrictive planning regime, there is an acute housing shortage in East Jerusalem. In addition, Palestinian houses are overcrowded and in a bad condition. The planning regime poses a difficult dilemma for Palestinian families: they have the choice between migrating outside the municipal area of Jerusalem (and losing their residency status) or building without the necessary building permit. According to UN OCHA, at least 32% of Palestinian structures in East Jerusalem lack such a permit, putting approximately 88 000 Palestinians at risk.

27. Buildings constructed without a permit are considered illegal by the Israeli authorities who issue demolition orders against them. Unofficial sources estimate that up to 1 500 ‘illegally’ built residential buildings in East Jerusalem currently have demolition orders against them. In the course of this year, UN OCHA recorded the demolition of 50 Palestinian-owned structures in East Jerusalem, thereby affecting over 250 people (half of whom are children). Families are not only fined for having constructed their houses without a permit, they can also be charged for the costs of the demolition. As a means to avoid such fines, some Palestinian families are carrying out so-called self-demolitions (estimated at 6 this year).

28. The Jerusalem municipality acknowledges the planning crisis in East Jerusalem. The city’s new planning policy for East Jerusalem, presented in December 2009, aims at a “significant expansion of the number of floors and of the building ratio with regard to the approved plan, many solutions for adding residential units in the area, and a response to the existing hardship”. According to some planning experts, however, the new policy will not cause any significant progress in the densely populated and poorly-maintained Palestinian neighbourhoods.

29. The take-over of Palestinian property is often associated with the eviction of Palestinian residents. Throughout 2010 there have been 3 cases where Palestinians have been forcibly evicted, two in the old city, one in Jabal Mukabber. In these cases, the properties have been taken over by Israeli settlers or settler organisations under police protection. These evictions have affected approximately 70 people this year. In Sheikh Jarrah, over 60 Palestinians lost their homes over the past years and an estimated
500 remain at risk of forced eviction, dispossession and displacement in the near future.

RESIDENCY STATUS
30. Restrictive measures continue to apply in relation to the ID and residency status of Palestinians from East Jerusalem. Following the Israeli occupation of East Jerusalem in 1967, Palestinian residents of the city have been given the civil status of “permanent residents” of Israel. This status gives them the right to live in Jerusalem and work in Israel without the need for a special permit. To retain this status residents are forced to regularly prove that they adhere to the strict criteria that demonstrates Jerusalem is the centre of their life. If they fail to convince the Israeli authorities their status is revoked and they lose their right to reside in the city. Between 1967 and mid-2010, some 14 000 Palestinian residents of Jerusalem have had their status revoked. Unlike Israeli citizenship, permanent residency is not automatically passed on to non-Jewish children, who only receive permanent residence under certain conditions. This leads to difficulties in the registration of children – where one parent is a Jerusalem resident and the other is from rest of the West Bank or Gaza Strip – with the Jerusalem Centre for Socio-Economic Rights estimating that there are as many as 10 000 unregistered children in East Jerusalem. The inability to become registered makes it very difficult for these children to access basic education, health and other social services. Around 5 500 children in school age are not registered and therefore do not attend school.
31. As permanent residency is not automatically transferred through marriage, a Palestinian resident of East Jerusalem who marries a Palestinian from the West Bank or Gaza Strip, and wishes to reside in the city with his/her spouse must apply for family unification. Applications for family reunification and ID cards and identification for children and spouses involve a long, expensive bureaucratic process. In 2003, Israel introduced the Nationality and Entry into Israel Law which disproportionately impacts residents of East Jerusalem, under which they are forbidden from family unification not only with their spouses, but also with their children.

32. In June this year, the Israeli authorities invoked “breach of loyalty to the state of Israel” in order to withdraw the residency rights for three members of the Palestinian Legislative Council as well as for a former Palestinian Minister of Jerusalem Affairs.

ACCESS AND MOVEMENT

33. The route of the separation barrier and its associated permit regime continue to have a serious humanitarian, social and economic impact on Palestinian life. It continues to sever the connection between East Jerusalem and the wider West Bank and between Palestinian communities in East Jerusalem itself.

34. The construction of the separation barrier in East Jerusalem, which started in 2002, continued throughout 2010. In the area around the Jerusalem municipality, the barrier measures around 168 kilometres, of which only 3 percent runs along the 1967 Green Line. The main reason behind this deviation is the integration of 12 Israeli settlements (and space for their future expansion).

35. The route of the barrier changes the de facto boundaries of Jerusalem and, in some cases, runs through the middle of densely populated Palestinian neighbourhoods. As a consequence, a number of Palestinian communities (such as Kafr ‘Aqab and Shu’fat) within the Jerusalem municipal boundary find themselves on the ‘West Bank’ side of the barrier. These communities need to cross checkpoints to access the health, education and other services to which they are entitled as residents of Jerusalem. The barrier also affects

16 West Bank localities which are trapped on the ‘Jerusalem’ side of the Barrier. These communities face uncertain residency status, impeded access to basic services and fear of displacement.

36. In April this year construction of the barrier around the Palestinian village of Al Walaja resumed. The construction works have led to the confiscation of land and the uprooting of trees. Once completed, the barrier will completely encircle the village (which will only be accessible through a tunnel) and cut off farmers from much of their agricultural land.

37. Palestinians who do not have residency rights in East Jerusalem or do not have Israeli citizenship need a permit to enter Jerusalem. Access for those Palestinians granted permits is restricted to three out of the 14 barrier checkpoints: Qalandiya, Gilo and Zaytoun. The permit is difficult and time consuming to obtain and is subject to a number of conditions, e.g. a time limit or a ban on driving a car or staying overnight. West Bank ID holders with permits for Jerusalem or Israel must enter and exit through the same checkpoint and risk having their permits revoked if this is not complied with. Permits are suspended during security closures and often during Jewish holidays.

EDUCATION
38. Inadequate numbers of classrooms, the substandard condition of existing facilities and several access restrictions have a severe impact on the educational sector in East Jerusalem. Many students fail to complete the secondary cycle and the drop-out rate is much higher than in West Jerusalem. Palestinian students face serious difficulties in reaching educational services, reporting longer journeys and delays in getting to educational facilities. The same holds true for students from Jerusalem who wish to attend a school on the other side of the separation barrier.

39. The East Jerusalem school system continues to have a shortage of approximately 1 000 classrooms; only 39 new classrooms have been built recently. Planning restrictions hinder the construction of new school facilities and some schools are threatened by demolition and sealing orders. Due to this shortage, children often study in overcrowded, makeshift classrooms in facilities that are not built for educational purposes and that lack libraries or even playgrounds. The Israeli NGO ACRI estimates that 50 percent of East Jerusalem classrooms were unsuitable or substandard in 2009. East Jerusalem students are also disadvantaged with regard to financing of education. According to the Jerusalem municipality, students attending primary schools in East Jerusalem receive only one fourth of the budget that students in other parts of the city receive. Only some 20 percent of the general municipal education budget is spent in East Jerusalem.

HEALTH
40. While East Jerusalemites on the Jerusalem side of the separation barrier have the possibility to enjoy Israeli health insurance and access to adequate health care, those Jerusalem residents caught on the “West Bank” side of the barrier regularly have their right to appropriate health-care denied.

41. Furthermore, key secondary and tertiary care which is not available in the West Bank or Gaza, including treatment for diabetes, cancer and cardiovascular disease, are only provided for by East Jerusalem’s hospitals (non-governmental). West Bank Palestinians, who make up about 60 percent of all admissions to these hospitals, require permits to enter Jerusalem for treatment. Patients needing emergency treatment available only in Jerusalem are especially affected by the delays caused by the Israeli access restrictions. General closures of checkpoints by Israeli authorities further impede access to the East Jerusalem hospitals for treatment as, except for emergency cases, other medical access permits become temporarily invalid; there were a total of 50 days of general closure in the 12-month period ending in March 2010.

42. Since 2008 all permit-holding medical personnel, excluding doctors, who live in the West Bank are only allowed to cross through the three main checkpoints (Qalandiya, Gilo and Zaytoun). Only doctors continue to have a special stamp on their permits allowing them to use any checkpoint to reach East Jerusalem. These further access restrictions result in long delays and impede the efficient functioning of hospitals and the delivery of quality health-care services.

43. East Jerusalem hospitals are prohibited by the Israeli Ministry of Health from importing medical equipment and medicine from the West Bank creating supply and logistical problems for the hospitals and resulting in higher costs. Furthermore each hospital has a quota for the number of new staff they can employ from the West Bank. Trainee medical personnel also require access to the hospitals in order to complete their studies (and therefore meet the future needs of health sector staffing) and some 90 percent of these students are from the West Bank. In June 2010 a number of these students were denied renewal of their permits by the Israeli authorities.

44. Though East Jerusalemites are included in and contribute to the Israeli health system their access to health care is also restricted by the security requirement for Israeli ambulance staff to enter Palestinian neighbourhoods in East Jerusalem only under police escort. Requests for the dispatch of ambulances regularly result in unnecessary, and potentially life-threatening, delays for Palestinian residents in East Jerusalem.

ECONOMY
45. The economic situation in East Jerusalem remains a major source of concern. The barrier continues to have a particularly adverse impact on the traditionally strong trade links between the West Bank and East Jerusalem. There are, for instance, restrictions on the import of dairy products and vegetables from the West Bank to East Jerusalem. A recent draft law aims at forbidding Palestinians to work as tour guides. This would not only deprive visitors of a Palestinian perspective on Jerusalem but also represent a significant cut in income for Palestinians in East Jerusalem.

46. While Palestinians constitute approximately 30 percent of the population in Jerusalem, approximately 10 percent of the municipal budget is spent in Palestinian areas. The provision of services in East Jerusalem by the Jerusalem Municipality is inadequate. Palestinian areas are characterized by poor roads, little or no street cleaning, limited sewage systems and an absence of well maintained public spaces, in sharp contrast to areas where Israelis live (in both West Jerusalem and East Jerusalem settlements).
47. Poverty figures in East Jerusalem are far higher than in other areas of the city. According to data published by the National Insurance Institute, 75,3 percent of Palestinian adults and 83,1 percent of Palestinian children in East Jerusalem live below the poverty line. Over 95 000 children in East Jerusalem are estimated to live in a permanent state of poverty.

TRANSPORT INFRASTRUCTURE
48. A number of completed or ongoing infrastructure projects contribute to the Israeli control over occupied East Jerusalem. A tramway/light rail will connect Israeli settlements in East Jerusalem with the centre in West Jerusalem. Its construction has continued throughout 2010 and is scheduled to be completed within the coming months. The first line of this tramway will pass through the Palestinian neighbourhood of Shu’fat and touch the southern border of Beit Hanina.

49. A separated and inferior set of roads for Palestinians is being set up around Jerusalem. A series of bypass roads, to the east of Jerusalem, are currently being built and will connect Palestinian neighbourhoods outside of the separation barrier north and south of Jerusalem. The apparent purpose of the Israeli authorities for these roads is to secure so-called “transport contiguity” for Palestinians living in the north and the south of the West Bank, who are in fact already denied travelling from Ramallah to Bethlehem through East-Jerusalem. It is intended that one of the main roads linking Hizma to Az
Zayyem will have restricted access by a further Israeli checkpoint in Anata (north of Ma’ale Adumim). It is separated by a wall from a parallel road reserved for Israeli vehicular use only, which connects the settlement of Ma’ale Adumim to Jerusalem.

50. At least two other roads are currently under construction: the first one is Route 20, a lateral bypass road that will create a direct link between road 443 (west of Ramallah) and Pisgat Zeev. It will be reserved for Israelis and Palestinian residents of Jerusalem. The second one is an additional access road south of Ma’ale Adumim, reserved for Israeli use only and aiming at facilitating traffic and access to Ma’ale Adumim. Land confiscations for another bypass road for Palestinian traffic have taken place south of the Ma’ale Adumim/E1 area. The cumulative effect of this new road grid will further restrict Palestinian traffic in the Ma’ale Adumim/E1 area. Bedouin communities, who are disregarded in the planning process, have already been displaced from this area.

PALESTINIAN INSTITUTIONS
51. In 1993 the then Foreign Minister of Israel in a letter to his Norwegian counterpart acknowledged the importance of Palestinian institutions in East Jerusalem, adding that their activities would not be hampered. In 2001, however, Israel decided to close most of these institutions. The Roadmap required Israel to reopen the institutions whilst the EU, in its December 2009 Council conclusions, also called for the reopening of Palestinian institutions.

52. Nonetheless, Israeli authorities continue to renew the order of closure of numerous institutions every six months (the latest on the 25 July, extending the closure for another six months as of the 9 August 2010), basing its decision on claims that the institutions are affiliated to the Palestinian Authority and, therefore, in violation of the Oslo Agreements. This development contributes to undermining the role of Jerusalem as an engine and centre of Palestinian society.

53. The institutional and leadership vacuum in East Jerusalem created by the prolonged closure of those institutions, in particular that of the Orient House, which functioned as the PLO focal point in East Jerusalem, remains a key concern. Palestinian politicians active in Jerusalem are subject to repressive measures by Israel. This void continues to seriously affect all spheres of life of Palestinians in East Jerusalem (political, economic, social and cultural) and foster a growing fragmentation of society at all levels, the isolation of communities and a weakened collective sense of identity. Equally worrisome is the general sense of neglect felt by many Palestinian East Jerusalemites and the absence of Palestinian state-sponsored institutions and secular organisations, as they allow more space for Islamic extremist organisations to extend their influence.

ACCESS TO RELIGIOUS SITES

54. Jerusalem is a city of significant importance to the three monotheistic religions and the location of many of their most sacred sites. Access restrictions and closure regimes, however continue to impede visits by Christian and Muslim religious worshippers to some of their holy sites, located in Jerusalem/the Old City, throughout the year. The restrictions are typically tightened during religious holidays. During the month of Ramadan, many Muslims cannot observe their prayers at the mosque of their choice, notably at the Al Aqsa Mosque. This was again the case in 2010, when access for Palestinians with West Bank IDs was restricted to men over 50 and women over 45 and boys and girls under 12. Men between 45 and50 and women between 30 and 45 had to apply for special permits. This implies that 40 percent of the West Bank population was denied access to Friday prayers. However, it should also be noted that the functioning of checkpoints around Jerusalem during the Ramadan period was more orderly than in the past.

55. In 2010 Israeli authorities again invoked security reasons to intensify the restrictions on the access of Christian pilgrims to the Old City during the Holy Fire Ceremony of Christian Orthodox Easter and Palm Sunday. Similar restrictions are not put in place for the Jewish population during their religious holidays. Furthermore, many believers of the Christian and Muslim faiths, for various reasons, face difficulties in obtaining or extending visas, including for visiting clergy. Members of churches and religious communities as well as volunteers working for them requesting long term visas are typically subject to long, complicated and opaque procedures.

THE HARAM AL-SHARIF/TEMPLE MOUNT

56. Developments at the Haram al-Sharif, or Temple Mount, are significant in several respects – they are a cause of tension locally between the various communities, but also receive attention globally, such as the large demonstrations by Muslims whenever they perceive the Muslim position in Jerusalem to be undercut. For this reason, this site is one of the most sensitive in Jerusalem and therefore, any event happening on it or around it is likely to have serious repercussions.

57. In 2010, the Haram al-Sharif/Temple Mount area continued to see heightened tension and inflammatory actions which led to riots and demonstrations in Palestinian neighbourhoods. Repeated provocative visits of the Haram area by Jewish radical political and religious groups, which continue to occur during 2010, are highly problematic. On several occasions Israeli forces entered Al Aqsa Mosque and confronted stone-throwing Muslims. The perceived threat to religious places promotes rumors which in turn can lead to violent encounters between the various groups.

58. The disputes regarding various construction projects (e.g.“archeological tunnels”, recent plans to alter of the Western Wall plaza) serve as examples of a lack of consensus-building by Israel around those projects in sensitive areas of the city. Work on the Mughrabi Gate has proven a particular example of this in 2010. The Waqf, the Islamic body responsible for the Haram al-Sharif compound, has expressed concern regarding the construction by the Israeli Authorities, without their agreement, of a new bridge to replace the collapsed ramp leading to the Mugrabi Gate. Work on the Mugrabi Gate, the passageway between the Wailing Wall Plaza and the Temple Mount / Haram al Sharif, started again in September after the Jerusalem District Court’s decision to authorize the work. The Waqf believe that the damage caused to the ramp is negligible and could be fixed without replacing the whole structure. They suspect this may be used as an opportunity to undertake new excavations under the ramp or as seemed to be originally planned (prior to the Court’s ruling against it) to expand the area of the Wailing Wall Plaza. A new plan for the Mughrabi Gate, revealed in November this year, seems to be less far-reaching in the sense that it does not include any expansion of the Plaza. The Waqf, however, was again not consulted in the process.

[Annex 2]

Reinforcing the EU policy on East Jerusalem

The submissions made by Heads of Mission in Jerusalem and Ramallah 2010 are largely congruent with those of 2009. Keeping in mind the sensitivity of the situation in Jerusalem, they have been drawn up in a spirit that aims to maintain the possibility of a two-state solution as set out in numerous statements by the EU, not least the Council Conclusions of 8 December 2009. They thus remain valid, but have been adapted and updated reflecting the situation as set out in this year’s report –highlighting specific actions aiming to maintain the Palestinian social fabric in East Jerusalem on a political, cultural and economic level.

A. East Jerusalem as the future Palestinian capital

  • 1) In conformity with the objectives of the Strategic Multi-sector Development Plan for
  • East Jerusalem, promote a coordinated approach and a coherent Palestinian strategy towards East Jerusalem.
  • 2) Promote the establishment of a PLO focal point/representative in East Jerusalem.
  • 3) National or Europe Day events to be held in East Jerusalem (when suitable at Palestinian institutions).
  • 4) EU missions with offices or residences in East Jerusalem to regularly host Palestinian officials with senior EU visitors.
  • 5) Avoid having Israeli security and/or protocol accompanying high ranking officials from Member States when visiting the Old City/East Jerusalem.
  • 6) Prevent/discourage financial transactions from EU MS actors supporting settlement activity in East Jerusalem, by adopting appropriate EU legislation.
  • 7) Compile non-binding guidelines for EU tour operators to prevent support for settlement business in East Jerusalem (e.g. hotels, bus operators, archaeological sites controlled by pro-settler organisations etc).
  • 8) Ensure that the EU-Israel Association Agreement is not used to allow the export to the
    EU of products manufactured in settlements in East Jerusalem.
  • 9) Raise public awareness about settlement products, for instance by providing guidance on origin labelling for settlement products to major EU retailers.
  • 10) Inform EU citizens of financial risks involved in purchasing property in occupied East Jerusalem.

B. Reopening of Palestinian institutions in East Jerusalem

  • 1) Highlight the reopening, as stipulated in the Road Map, of Palestinian institutions in high level meetings with Israeli representatives, as well as in the EU and Quartet discussions and statements.
  • 2) Host Palestinian Jerusalem civil society events in cultural offices, consulates and diplomatic residences until institutions are reopened.
  • 3) Explore the use of Palestinian institutions to promote joint EU-PLO interests.

C. Economic and social rights of the Palestinian population

  • 1) Provide assistance to ensure that Palestinians are included in the development of urban master-plans in East Jerusalem in order for i.e. Palestinian housing needs to be met.
  • 2) In high level meetings, stress the EU’s serious concerns regarding inadequate emergency services, e.g ambulances, fire fighting and policing for all residents in East
    Jerusalem.
  • 3) Coordinate, fund and support projects in East Jerusalem.

D. Religious and cultural dimension of the city

  • 1) Support and encourage inter-faith dialogue in Jerusalem.
  • 2) Encourage Arab countries to acknowledge the multicultural dimension of Jerusalem,
    including its Jewish and Christian heritage.
  • 3) Engage in informing (e.g. web sites etc) EU citizens undertaking visits on the political
    situation in East Jerusalem.
  • E. Strengthen the role of the European Union
    1) Enhance local coordination between Quartet actors for input into policy making and decisions.
  • 2) Ensure EU presence when there is a risk of demolitions or evictions of Palestinian families.
  • 3) Ensure EU presence at Israeli courts cases on house demolitions or evictions of Palestinian families.
  • 4) Ensure EU intervention when Palestinians are arrested or intimidated by Israeli authorities for peaceful cultural, social or political activities in East Jerusalem.

5) Operationalise the EU policy on bringing high level visitors to sensitive sites (e.g. separation barrier etc).

  • - on logistics for high level visitors (e.g choice of hotel, change of transport East/West)
  • - on contacts with the Jerusalem Mayor and on refraining from meeting Israeli officials in their East Jerusalem offices (e.g. in the Israeli Ministry of Justice etc)
  • - on information sharing on violent settlers in East Jerusalem to assess whether to grant entry into the EU.

Possibly related posts (automatically generated):

  1. Colonel Baruch Nagar Colonel Baruch Nagar is an extremist member of the right wing party of Likud, Nagar entertains notions of Jewish racial...
  2. Ilan Paz Brigadier General (Ret.) Ilan Paz, “תא”ל (מיל’) אילן פז” a.k.a. “Pitzi”. (מיל’) a.k.a. “Binyamin”. Paz lives near Haifa, in the...
  3. A Holocaust Survivor Writes to Obama and Olmert —– Original Message —– From: Eva S. Moseley To: Prime.Minister’sOffice [at] it [dot] pmo [dot] gov [dot] il Sent: Thursday,...
  4. UN Employees Disrespect UN Resolutions Boycott Ahava Dead Sea Cosmetics Today I received the latest news sent to me by the women in black in...
  5. Boston Globe Dear Kawther, here is a letter to our local newspaper, which it probably won’t publish. See 3rd paragraph especially. Article...

Thursday, April 29, 2010

To Live and Love in Palestine

To Live and Love in Palestine

“To Live and Love in Palestine” is a literary, musical and cultural evening which will take place on May 7 2010 in the Odeon in Vienna. The event is organized by Society for Austro-Arab Relations headed by Mr. Fritz Edlinger. Dr. Sahar Khalifeh, a famous Palestinian writer and novelist will take part in the event next to the famous Austrian actor of theater and television, and film director Karl-Heinz Hackl, who will read part of his book in German. Musician Marwan Abdo will perform typical Arab music at the event. At the end of the evening, a dialogue between Khalifeh and Viola Raheb will be featured.

Marwan Abdo, born 1967 in Beirut, Lebanon, is a Palestinian refugee. As a child he experiences the fate of living the Diaspora. In 1985 moved to Austria to continue his studies, In Vienna he finds a new home as musician, singer, composer and poet Abdo´s instrument, the Oud (the oriental, short-necked lute), is for the Arabian music nearly of the same importance as the piano in the Western culture, his music has its roots in the classical Arabic music which is not restricted to particular rhythms. (Read More about Marwan Abdo). (Click on pictures to see them bigger).

Sahar Khalifeh is a Palestinian writer and novelist born in 1942 in the occupied city of Nablus in the West Bank. She received a BA in English and American Literature from Bir Zeit University in 1977, a Diploma in Creative Writing from the University of Iowa, 1978, a MA in English and American Literature from the University of North Carolina – Chapel Hill, USA in 1982. She received a Ph.D. in Women Studies & ِAmerican Women’s Literature from the University of Iowa, USA in 1988.

Sahar Khalifeh wrote the famous novels “We Are No More Your Slave Girls”, “Wild Thorns”, “Sunflower”, “Memoirs of an Unrealistic Woman”, “Al Saha”, “The Inheritance”, “The Picture, the Icon, and the Covenant”, “Hot Spring, Roots and Branches”, “The Door of the Courtyard”

On May 5 2010 Sahar Khalifeh will hold a lecture in St. Poelten. The theme of her speech will be “Caught between Western Prejudices and Islamic Fundamentalists”. The text of her speech follows below. The text was sent to me by Mr. Fritz Edlinger of SAAR, who organized this cultural event and also other activities of Sahar Khalifeh.

Caught Between Western Prejudices and Islamic Fundamentalists – By Sahar Khalifeh

Before delving into the core of my presentation in which I explain how we Palestinians, we Arabs, We Arab women are caught up between Western Prejudices and Islamic Fundamentalists, allow me first to introduce myself. I am a Palestinian, I am an Arab, and I am a Moslem. In short, I am a Moslem Palestinian Arab woman. This means, according to the Western media and Western traditional prejudices, that I am a dangerous creature who belongs to a dangerous culture that has a fixed nature, unable to be converted, unable to change. According to those prejudices, we Moslem Arabs are fixed in one static reality, in one static phase. A Palestinian is a synonym to a terrorist; an Arab is a synonym to a filthy, greasy sheikh with a beard and beads, a camel in the background and a dagger behind his back. We are reduced to a picture that does not change in time or seen under a different light: A Moslem Ben Laden, a Moslem fundamentalist, a Moslem terrorist, a Moslem wrapped up woman, a Moslem filthy oil- sheikh. We are fixed in one reality, one image, one picture which is considered real and true.

But, is there an image, which is real and true? Is there a reality that is fixed in nature, which is unmovable and unable to change? Let us remember the findings of the great impressionist artist Cezanne, who used to study the effect of changing light on the same landscape or view. What he found out is that the same landscape, or view, under different light produces different pictures. He also found out that we see the same view differently through our 2 different eyes. I mean the right eye and the left eye do not see the same view the same way because each eye sees the view from a different angle! So, if a pair of eyes of the same person see the same view differently, can we infer then that the same view cannot but be seen differently by 2 different people? Can we also infer that not only light or different eyes make things look different, also different times, different imaginations, emotions, prejudices and pre-conditioned concepts can have the same impact on vision and sight?

Let me show you from real examples, from down-to-earth experiences that things cannot be static and people can never be fixed in one reality, in one static phase.

I started by saying that I am an Arab woman, assuming that an Arab woman is a fixed reality or an unchanging identity that is clear and complete. It sounds as if I assume that an Arab woman is a being, or a creature, or a substance that is seen or comprehended the same way by all. But, as we all know, a woman in the Arab culture, and many other cultures, means the weak sex, the other sex, the unequal sex, the sex that does not inherit the legacy or perpetuate the family’s name, the sex that can bring children as much as it can bring dreadful shame. Within the family where I was borne, I was received with disappointment that reached sobs and tears. Everybody was waiting for a boy. To their dismay, I was a girl. I was the fifth girl in a raw, which meant that I was the fifth disappointment, or what my mother considered her fifth defeat. Compared to my uncle’s wife who victoriously produced 10 precious boys, my mother was a loser, an unblessed wife. My uncle used to tease his brother, my father, by saying: “Don’t worry brother, my sons will carry my name and yours! My mother was more beautiful, more intelligent and more dignified than my uncle’s wife and all other wives in the family. Nevertheless, every one looked at her as the least productive, with no valuable fruits.

I inherited those prejudices and concepts. Since childhood I repeatedly heard them say that we girls of the family, girls of the neighborhood, and all girls of the world were powerless, helpless, a sex doomed by nature, the sex that is permanently weak. Thus, as far as I can remember, I started my fight with nature since I was a child.

As a child, they considered me rebellious, over dynamic, very loud and fussy and uneasy to cope with. I wanted to prove that despite my doomed nature, I was good and worthy, bright and clever, cute and funny. I could make people giggle with laughter and fill them with joy. I wanted to prove that I was important as my adored brother – the only boy among six girls – and that I deserved the same importance and love. Of course, I failed. For years, I failed. People continued saying: women are weak, women are worthless, and women are nameless. They do not inherit the legacy or perpetuate the family’s name.

To my surprise, and I hope to yours, a few months ago, my younger sister told me that she accidentally discovered that I was the only member within the Khalifeh family, which is as large as a tribe, whose name was listed in the Palestinian encyclopedia. With a sigh of relief, she added: “Not my father, not my brother, not my uncle with his 10 precious boys, not any male in the family was mentioned in our encyclopedia, it was only you!” I also sighed with relief and told her: “My dear sister, you have to notice that many women are also listed in the Egyptian encyclopedia, the Syrian encyclopedia, the Lebanese encyclopedia, the Algerian, the Moroccan and the rest of Arab encyclopedias? Things are changing. Things have changed!

When I say that things change I mean that things are not static. Things are moving. Things are apt to change. For me as an Arab woman, I passed different phases, I was transformed by currents, and I was a transmitter of change. Even among the most conservative Arab families, women now go to school. When they earn education, they become teachers, doctors, engineers, pharmacists, writers and journalists, musicians and artists. Many women are now considered indispensable, stronger than men, more creative than men and more important than men. Things have changed.

But mind you. When I see our image in the Western media as dreadful creatures wrapped up in their chadors, with masques of leather, harems behind their veils, I ask with amazement: “Why do they see us fixed in one reality, in one static phase?! They draw us a picture that is constantly gloomy, seen through one single light! Is this what they consider a true picture? Do they think that God has created us differently than the rest of the female sex, unable to change?!”

Now let me tell you the story of how I was introduced to a reality that does not believe in a static reality. How I discovered that what people in a certain culture consider true is not the Truth because things are not fixed or static, because things keep moving , keep changing in essence and shape.

When I was still a child, I had a teacher who constantly mentioned the word Change in different tones and meanings. He mentioned the word Change when he spoke about social justice. He mentioned Change when he spoke about a fair distribution of Arab wealth. He mentioned Change when he spoke about Arab women’s status and he mentioned Change when he spoke about Arab out-of-date regimes. Everyone I new respected and admired that teacher. The young ones wanted to be like him, the old ones were keen to hide him when the police chased him.

When I became a teenager, I discovered that my great teacher was not the only one who spoke about Change and justice. Most of our educated people believed in and spoke for those beliefs and thoughts. I also discovered that thousands of our enlightened men, similar to my teacher, were either chased by the police or rotting in jails of regimes supported and nourished by Western powers: British, French, and later on the Americans.

Until the mid sixties, the national and international policies of our great nationalist leader: Abdul Nasser encouraged that mood for liberation and change. His influence was so great that a number of successful codetta took place in different Arab states. The West considered him a threat to Western interests and their reactionary allies in the region, but we thought we were witnessing the beginning of real good change.

The fifties and sixties were the golden era of Arab nationalism. The Arab street was full of vigor and hope for transformation. Our attitude towards our traditional socio-political systems was rebellious and sharply critical. We reflected our themes of liberation and social justice in our literature, our theater, our songs, music, and the idioms we used in our daily life. Literature from all over the world was pouring into our culture. In our bookshops and on street pavements you could find existentialist literature, socialist literature, black literature and every literature that called for liberation, revolution and change.

That mood for liberation and change influenced everyone including the illiterate peasants. Women too were touched. They started to go out in the street without their veils. Tens of thousands of young women graduated from universities. Some of them started to get involved in politics and enrolled in political parties. Women not only took their veils off, they also wore the sleeveless and mini skirts. We were dancing tango and Rock and Roll, listening to Western songs and music despite our hatred to the West. We wanted to be like the West but not under its domination or control.

That entire dream-like atmosphere came to a halt when Israel, backed by the West, defeated Nasser in 1967. That defeat represented the defeat of our national movement and our socialist beliefs. The Americans and their conservative allies in the region took that opportunity. They forcefully supported the move away from our leftist nationalism by backing the Islamists. They poured millions of dollars in that direction. The Moslem Brothers’ party, which was completely ignored by the masses started to gain power. What happened in our region in the seventies and eighties was very much similar to what happened in Afghanistan when the Americans supported the Islamists, including Ben Laden, to bring down the left. A similar scenario, almost the same, took place in our region. Surprisingly, to America’s dismay, the Islamists turned their back against their supporters once they took hold of the street. They became a crystallized power. They no longer needed America. After being pampered and nourished by America, America started calling them “terrorists,” and Europe followed the American style. That was the time when we started witnessing the birth of a new era which we ironically defined as change, but what kind of change!

In Palestine, the Israelis copied the American model. They encouraged the Islamists to stand in the face of the nationalist-socialist PLO. While they were chasing, harassing and assassinating PLO leaders and activists, they pretended not to see what the Islamists were doing to women and society at large. They even favored them in educational positions. They infiltrated thousands of them, men and women, in our educational system. Thus, the Islamists gained more power through influencing students at an early age. Once they were sure of their grip, they turned their forces against the West and Israel. They became a crystallized power. What helped them reach that stage was not just the nationalist – socialist defeat deepened by the downfall of the Soviet Block. Nor was it the early American- Israeli support. The mal-administration of many corrupt leaders of the PLO added to their success.

Historically, after the defeat of 1967, the PLO filled the gap created by Nasser’s absence. Arab revolutionists clustered around the PLO hoping to bring change to the entire region. During the seventies and eighties, the PLO represented the force that could bring socio-political change and unity against our conservative regimes. Unfortunately, by time, the PLO itself became not much different from other conservative, corrupt Arab regimes. The PLO leaders were either affected by the Arab petro-dollar or lost track and vision by losing a great number of their distinguished intellectuals that were assassinated by the Israeli Mossad. Those who made the Oslo agreement were certainly not the brightest. They failed as administrators as much as they failed in bringing peace. Their corruption added to people’s poverty, and the Israelis made it impossible for them to bring stability and hope. People started to be fed up and bitter. Writers, journalists, artists and intellectuals were writing, calling, begging for change, with no avail. The masses, beaten by poverty, lack of vision and hope turned to the Islamists. They meant to bring to power a front that could rid them of poverty, corruption and occupation. This is how Hamas won the elections in Palestine. This is how Hamas took over Gaza. This is how the Arab masses are turning towards the Islamists to rid them of poverty, and defeat.

We are now in a mess. Israel is taking advantage of this mess. Beside the continuation of occupation and the building up of new settlements, thousands of settlements that leave us no space to breath, every year, or every other year Israel launches a new operation or war similar to the one you saw on TV taking place in Gaza. They shell; they rocket, they kill and destroy. They destroy the infrastructure of towns and villages. They destroy electricity plants, water systems, sewage systems, hospitals, homes, buildings, and refugee camps. They destroy UN and NGO offices, storage places of wheat and flour, milk and sugar, gasoline stations, cars, buses and even ambulances. They wound and kill hundreds, at times thousands of Innocent civilians, including women and children.

As you might see, I told you my story as a woman, as a Palestinian, and as an Arab. I told you those stories from my perspective, from my experiences, and from my beliefs, which I consider real and true. But for you as Westerners, from what you have learnt or came to believe, you might have different thoughts, beliefs or visions about all what I have mentioned, right? This is normal and understandable. You know why? Because we too as Arabs, as Palestinians and as Arab women have different beliefs and visions about your culture, about your history and about your behaviors. But what we see, and what you see, is it true and real? Is it the Truth? We have to raise these question unless we are satisfied with our prejudices and fixed in our traditional beliefs.

To wrap up, let me remind you of Cezanne’s discovery about the connection between light and sight. How a scene or a view looks differently under a different light. In this context, allow me to revise the different cultural prejudices seen differently under different lights.

First prejudiced image: I examined women’s nature as seen through the eyes of a traditional society that considers women unchangeable, permanently helpless, and unable to inherit their families’ legacies or perpetuate their families’ names. How can I define that image, true or false? Please answer, true or false? False.

Second prejudiced image: I examined Arab women’s image as presented in Western media. That image assumes that Arab women are harems trapped in their veils as much as they are trapped in time. They are permanently helpless, frozen in one static phase. That image ignores women like me; ignores the presence of thousands like me that fight against sexism, racism, colonization and occupation. That image ignores the presence of millions of younger women that fight for education, light and liberty. They fight against the prejudices of the East and those of the West. They fight to be able to inherit their families’ legacies and perpetuate their families’ names. A number of them will ultimately succeed, as I did, in printing their names in Arabic encyclopedias and leaving their marks in our modern history. The one-sided image about Arab women, presented in the West, how can I define it, true or false? Please answer, true or false? False.

Third prejudiced image: Western media presents Moslems as fundamentalists, Moslems as terrorists, Moslems as Ben Ladens, thousands of Ben Ladens hidden in every corner of the Middle East. Arabs have one static nature that produces violence, one-track mindedness, one-track social structure that ultimately gives birth to corruption and reactionary backward regimes. Western media forgets to mention that historically, the West has supported reactionary backward regimes against the will of their people to protect Western interests. Western media forgets to mention that historically, Western powers had helped the Islamic fundamentalists to have power and control in our region, just like what happened in Afghanistan. That image about Arabs as having one reality, trapped in one static phase, how can we define it, true or false? Please answer, true or false? False.

The final image is about Israel. Israel is the only enlightened, secular democracy in the Middle East. Israel is not racist. Israel is not sexist. Israel is not religionist that discriminates against other religions and creeds. Israel is a permanent ally that protects Western interests in the Middle East. Villains, powerful villains, very well armed villains, that are full of hatred, that are full of grudge, ready to kill and ruin, surround innocent Israel. Those villains do not listen to reason or common sense, do not obey international law, ignore UN resolutions, kill and destroy with highly organized force, on their way to develop nuclear weapons and phosphorus bombs. How can I define that image? Is it true? Is it real? Is it reality? I will not answer this question; I leave it to you to think about.

Now I would like to examine the concept of “freedom of expression.” In the West, or in the First World, as we call it, they assume that suppression in the Third World or in Arab countries makes it difficult, or even impossible to say the Truth. But, my dear friends, with all the freedom of expression you have in the West, I just showed you that you receive images that look differently through different eyes affected by different lights! Where is the Truth in what you see? Where is the Truth in what we all see? In the West, there is a tendency to put all Palestinians, all Arabs, and all Arab women in one static image, in one static phase. We too in the Arab world, and perhaps in other Third World cultures, we see the West as whole as one entity, one identity and one frozen face.

Not only the media that tends to show things differently or draw twisted conclusions or put all images in one single frame. Also religion, politics, race, sex and interests, all these can twist images and play a role in forming impressions and framing minds. From my place in the Middle East, with my identity as a Palestinian, as an Arab, as a Moslem woman, how dare I talk about the Truth? Can any one here tell me if we ever can reach the Truth?

Where did I reach with my rambling thoughts and scattered images? That there is no Truth to believe in or work for? That we are all victims of prejudiced cultures. This is really absurd! It is unfair and depressing. For we human beings, despite our difference, our fences and our limited spheres and visions we all share one Truth that is absolutely true and worthy, that is bright and hopeful, that is worth living for and dying for. It is the Truth that is based on love and liberty. Love for all and liberty for all. And again, despite our differences of race, religion, sex and politics, we all need love, we all need warmth, we all need intimacy. We all need to be recognized as humans, sensitive humans, tender humans and capable humans. We all need to communicate our thoughts and feelings. We all need to hold and embrace. Since childhood until we become very old, we need to love and be loved. We search for love, we cry for love, and at times, we die for love. We break into pieces when we lose love or feel betrayed by love. Is there a truth beyond this truth, more real, more genuine, and more precious and worthy?

And liberty. Is there a human being who does not seek liberty or spends a whole life searching for liberty? We call it liberty that leads to freedom, freedom of the body, freedom of the soul, freedom of the heart, freedom of the mind and freedom of speech. So there is a Truth I believe in despite my suspicions and critical mind. Deep in my heart, I believe that people deserve love, love and liberty that make them whole, fill them with light.

Did you believe me when I started my talk saying that there is no Truth that is eternally fixed? Did you believe me? Well, that wasn’t true, it was a trick, a game, or what we call in literature, a technique. All what I meant is to draw your attention, to shake some prejudices and shed different colors on different lights and sights. I hope you forgive me, I hope you recognize me, I hope you love me despite differences of color and light, vision and sight.


Possibly related posts (automatically generated):

  1. The Former Leader of Gaza Death Squads Mohammed Dahlan, who deceived the Europeans and the Americans, who financed his defeated army of death squads, the army that...
  2. Over 13 Honor Killings in Two Months in Palestine Seven women were killed in the Palestinian territories because of “honor killings” in the first month of the year 2010....

Saturday, December 5, 2009

The UN Must End Israel War Crimes

The UN Must End Israel War Crimes

000_8471aFollowing the activities of the “Annual Observance of the International Day of Solidarity with the Palestinian People” which was held on December 1 2009 at the UN center in Vienna in which Mr. Antonio Maria Costa, the UNOV General-Director, left the room after about 20 minutes and before listening to the speech of the Palestinian representative, the statement of International Progress Organization on behalf of the network of NGOs, the League of Arab States on behalf of Mr. Amr Mousa, the Non-Aligned Movement, the Organizations of the Islamic Conference (OIC).

The Israeli war crimes took the first place in the words of all the speakers. Mr. Amr Mousa called on the need of the UN and its official institutions, to carry their legal responsibilities and duties towards the war crimes committed by Israeli occupation forces against the Palestinian civilians.

[larger pictures click on to see them in full]

000_8478

He said: “ War crimes committed by the Israeli occupying forces against Palestinian civilians should not go unaccounted for or unpunished, because they are a flagrant violation of the existing legal norms, treaties and international agreements. The United Nations and it’s specialized agencies are urged to exercise their legal responsibilities with regard to these crimes and their perpetrators.


Mr. Fritz Edlinger said: I think it’s time that the International Community accepts 2009_02_20 1044athis lesson of almost two decades more or less of useless negotiations and put much more pressure on Israel in order to fulfill obligations. As I mentioned before, equal and fair negotiations between the occupier and the victim of the occupation area contradiction per se. It is about time that especially the UN, but also Europe accept this experience. I think it’s time to go back to more international approach. The frustrating and endless bilateral negotiations should at least be complemented by an International Peace Conference under the shared responsibility of the members of the Quartet.

Here are some paragraphs from the statement of Mr. Amr Mousa, which was read by Amb. Dr. Mikhail Wehbe, and under it some paragraphs of the statement of Mr. Fritz Edlinger, Secretary General of SAAR on behalf of the IPO.

Paragraphs From the Speech of Mr. Amr Mousa

Ladies and Gentlemen,

This year the annual commemoration of International Day of Solidarity with the Palestinian people takes place at a time when the Palestinian people continues to be deprived of its legitimate national rights, and to endure the continued Israeli occupation of it’s territory.

The Israeli military aggression and the siege of the Gaza Strip has brought a serious deterioration of the socio-economic and environmental situation and affects the health and daily life of the Palestinian people.

Ladies and Gentlemen,

The war crimes committed by the Israeli occupying forces against Palestinian civilians Amr Mousashould not go unaccounted for or unpunished, because they are a flagrant violation of the existing legal norms, treaties and international agreements. The United Nations and it’s specialized agencies are urged to exercise their legal responsibilities with regard to these crimes and their perpetrators.
The report of all investigative missions and international organizations working in the field of Human Rights, especially the Goldstone report of the Human Rights Councils fact-finding mission, the report of the Independent International Commission of Inquiry set up by the League of Arab States and headed by John Dugard, as well as the report of the UN Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights in the occupied Palestinian territories which has recently been submitted to the General Assembly of the United Nations, confirmed the war crimes committed under the Israeli occupation.

000_8569

They also documented Israel’s targeting of Palestinian civilians used as human shields and the use of internationally banned weapons.
The reports included testimonials and factual information about violations by the Israeli army of the Fourth Geneva Convention, in particular targeting of civilians and destruction of civilian religious, health and education facilities.

000_8613

Mr. Amr Mousa said that the Arabs are unanimous in upholding the Arab Peace Initiative and in supporting international efforts towards the two-stats solution. This, in addition to backing the notion of a fair and comprehensive settlement of the Arab-Israeli conflict, based on all relevant international resolutions and of a peace process conducted within the agreed upon frame of reference.

Mr. Amr Mousa expressed his deep concern over the recent step back taken by the U.S administration on the issue of Israeli settlement which are a serious obstacle to a just and comprehensive peace in the region.

Ladies and Gentlemen,

Israel’s arrogant disregard for international law, including human rights law, is due to the protection and immunity it enjoys. This injustice has still not been remedied because in Security Council has been prevented from dealing with the situation in the occupied territories.

Mr. Amr Mousa said that Israel’s attitude puts us face to face our 000_8540humanitarian, legal and political responsibilities. We must take all necessary steps to ensure that any future negotiations shall be serious and based on precise obligations, backed with guarantees that Israeli will not resort to its usual stalling tactics in order to prolong the occupation and change the situation on the ground in the occupied territories, ultimately making it impossible to establish a Palestinian State.

A complete halt to settlement activities in the occupied Palestinian territories, including Easy Jerusalem, and end to the unjust blockade of the Gaza Strip, the opening of the crossing points and of a humanitarian corridor to cater to the needs of the population and permit the reconstruction of Gaza are the essential points to be addressed in any meaningful and effective negotiations. Failing that, the situation will remain volatile and the region sitting on a powder keg.

000_8680The speech of Amr Mous ended by saying that the League of Arab States calls for adherence to the standards and principles which the international community enshrined in the United Nations Charter then reiterated in all resolutions relevant to the question of Palestinian and the Arab-Israeli Conflict and this, away from unbalanced politics and double standards.

The Arab League reaffirms once again that what it seeks is a genuine peace which would restore to the rightful owners their land and their right. So as to usher in a new era in the Middle East as a whole.

Paragraphs From the Speech of Mr. Fritz Edlinger

I would like to start my speech by sharing a couple of experiences I gained over the last week.

Too often we forget resp. forget to mention, that there is still 2009_02_20 1044aoccupation in Palestine, a very brutal one that has lasted 42 years. Israel is the occupying power in flagrant violation of basic parts of international law and against humanity. I just came back from Palestine a few days a go, and although I have visited Palestine at least 3-4 times a year over the last 40 years. I am still shocked at the dimensions of this occupation. The so-called security-barrier is almost totally finished, settlements are growing in all parts of the West Bank and the infrastructure for new settlements is built. And the Judaisation of Jerusalem in continuing at an accelerated speed. All these steps are in flagrant violation of international law and against countless resolutions and decisions by the UN and other international bodies.

The second fact I experienced, which is too often neglected is the 000_8693existence of millions of Palestinian refugees, who were kicked out of their homes in 1948 mostly within a fe hours. These events mark the initial-point of the national catastrophe of the Palestinian people, enshrined as Nakba in collective memory of the Palestinians. The number of appr. 800,000 deportees of 1948 increased in the meantime to almost 5 million, finding refuge in the Arab neighbor-countries and being registered and supported by the UNRWA. Israel did not just steal their land and all their properties but has been denying their right of return to their homeland for the last 62 years. Israel is not even ready to recognize the crime against humanity, which was committed in 1948, nor is it ready to offer any compensation. All these atrocities are against human rights and international law.

Mr. Edlinger said that the elimination of the Israeli occupation and their right of return are both important cornerstones of any political solution of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. They have to be addressed and not as done during the last 16, 17 years, the years of the so called peace-process-neglected and forgotten.

000_8588

Mr. Edlinger said that the pre- condition for any lasting peace, is the internal reconciliation of the Palestinian people and by saying that I do not mean the notorious conflict between Fatah and Hamas. I also mean the increasing conflict, or better to say, alienation, between inside and outside, taking into consideration that the vast majority of the Palestinian people are still living in exile. It is extremely important to give the millions of Palestinians in the Middle East, in Europe and in America definitely more influence in the different Palestinian bodies.

As long as the Palestinians continue their internal debates and conflicts, they will play into the hands of the Israelis. In both contexts I call for much more active involvement of the International Community. The international boycott against Gaza is inhuman and the one against Hamas in counter-productive, both are at the end only in Israel’s interest.

He ended his speech by saying that the International Day of Solidarity with the Palestinian People should not just used for diplomatic events. As important as they are, they should also be used to mobilize the International Civil Society and all peace-loving and law-abiding people in the world.

000_8697

Mr. Amr Mousa called on the need of the UN and its official institutions, to carry their legal responsibilities and duties towards the war crimes committed by Israeli occupation forces against the Palestinian civilians. He said:


by Kawther Salam

Possibly related posts (automatically generated):

  1. Petition for Israel War Crimes Tribunal A petition forwarded to me by Dr. Tammam Kelani, the president of Arab-Austrian Federation of Doctors and Pharmacists, follows below....
  2. A Palestinian Child Against Israel at The ICC Click on pictures to see them bigger. Netherlands/ The Hague, Amira Al-Qirim, a Palestinian girl aged 15, a victim and...
  3. Decision of Collaborators Furthers Palestinian Genocide Addameer, Al Haq, Al Mezan, Badil, Civic Coalition for Jerusalem, DCI- Palestine. NSAN Centre, Independent Commission for Human Rights, Jerusalem...
  4. EU and The Israeli War Crimes in Gaza The 25th annual conference of the Arab medical doctors in Europe and the 21st annual conference of the Union of...
  5. Israel Criticized Sharply at the UN in Vienna Note: I will publish the other speeches given during the event in follow-up articles. See more photos Tuesday, 1 December...